Limits of the LSI
Passing hop tests does not rule out the risk of re-injury: distance symmetry can hide differences in movement quality.
The LSI can also overestimate knee function. After an ACL rupture the healthy limb can itself be deficient, which inflates the index: the healthy limb is not always a reliable reference, because its pre-injury function is not guaranteed.
The LSI should therefore be part of an overall decision that includes quadriceps strength, psychological readiness, the demands of the target sport and movement quality.